When the meeting room goes quiet

A manager presents a new plan to the team and ends with the usual question: any objections? Nobody speaks. The manager thanks everyone and closes the meeting, pleased that the plan was accepted. Two months later the plan is behind schedule, and in the corridor people say they knew from the start it would not work.

What silence can mean

Silence in a meeting is rarely agreement. It can mean: I did not fully understand, and I do not want to be the only one who asks. It can mean: the decision is already taken, so why speak. And sometimes it means: the last person who objected paid for it.

Ask a different question

“Any objections?” invites a no. Try instead: “What could make this plan fail?” Now a person who points out a problem is helping, not opposing. The answers come more easily, and they are the ones you needed to hear.

Speak last

When the most senior person in the room gives an opinion first, the discussion is over before it starts. Let the others speak, beginning with the newest member of the team, and give your own view at the end.

Mind the first objection

Everyone watches how the first person who disagrees is treated. If the answer is a sharp reply, there will be no second objection that day, or that year. “Thank you, tell me more” costs four words and changes what the team dares to say.

And when a colleague is always quiet in meetings, ask them beforehand, alone. Some of the best remarks are never made in front of ten people.

All articles

More articles